Skip to main content
Shoulder SurgerySecond Opinion Guide

Should you get a second opinion for reverse shoulder replacement?

Reverse total shoulder replacement is designed for patients with both significant arthritis and an irreparable rotator cuff tear. It is the right operation for the right patient, but using it when rotator cuff function is intact or when a standard anatomic replacement would work leads to suboptimal results. A second opinion is appropriate to confirm this is the right type of shoulder replacement for your situation.

Red flags - consider a second opinion if you notice these

  • The status of your rotator cuff was not clearly established before recommending reverse replacement
  • You are under 65 with an intact rotator cuff
  • Standard anatomic shoulder replacement was not discussed as an option
  • Shoulder arthroscopy as a less invasive alternative was not considered
  • Expected range of motion outcomes were not discussed - reverse replacement does not restore full elevation in all patients

Questions to ask the second surgeon

  1. 1Is my rotator cuff truly irreparable, or could it be repaired at the time of shoulder replacement?
  2. 2Why is reverse replacement better for me than anatomic replacement?
  3. 3How many reverse shoulder replacements do you perform per year?
  4. 4What range of motion can I realistically expect?
  5. 5What activities will I need to permanently avoid to protect the implant?
  6. 6If this fails, what are my revision options?

What to expect from a second opinion visit

A second opinion for reverse shoulder replacement should come from a surgeon who specializes in shoulder surgery and performs both types of replacement regularly. Bring your shoulder MRI and X-rays. The critical question is the integrity of your rotator cuff - specifically whether it is repairable or truly irreparable.

Common questions

How long does reverse shoulder replacement last?
Implant survivorship at 10 years is approximately 80-90% in most published series. Scapular notching (bone erosion near the implant) is common but does not always affect outcomes. Younger and more active patients face higher risk of implant-related complications over time.
Can I use my arm normally after reverse shoulder replacement?
Most patients achieve functional use of the arm for activities below shoulder level - dressing, eating, driving, and light household tasks. Overhead function varies significantly. Heavy lifting and overhead sports are generally discouraged. Expectations should be set around function, not athletic performance.

Find a Shoulder Surgery specialist for a second opinion

Search board-certified surgeons by specialty, location, and accepted insurance - free for patients.

Find a specialist About Reverse Shoulder Replacement
All second opinion guides