Skip to main content
Shoulder SurgerySecond Opinion Guide

Should you get a second opinion for shoulder replacement?

Shoulder replacement is less common than knee or hip replacement, and the decision is more nuanced - particularly the choice between anatomic and reverse shoulder replacement. A second opinion is appropriate if the type of replacement being recommended was not clearly explained, if you are younger than 60, or if your rotator cuff status was not factored into the surgical plan.

Red flags - consider a second opinion if you notice these

  • The difference between anatomic and reverse total shoulder replacement was not explained
  • Your rotator cuff integrity was not assessed as part of the decision
  • Physical therapy and injections were not tried first
  • The surgeon did not discuss expected range of motion outcomes
  • Shoulder hemiarthroplasty (partial replacement) was not mentioned as a possible option

Questions to ask the second surgeon

  1. 1Why are you recommending anatomic vs. reverse total shoulder replacement for me?
  2. 2What is the status of my rotator cuff and how does it affect the recommendation?
  3. 3How many shoulder replacements do you perform per year?
  4. 4What range of motion should I realistically expect after surgery?
  5. 5What does shoulder replacement revision surgery involve if my implant fails?
  6. 6Would I be a candidate for shoulder resurfacing instead?

What to expect from a second opinion visit

For shoulder replacement, consider seeking a surgeon who specializes in shoulder surgery specifically, rather than a general orthopedist. Bring your shoulder X-rays and MRI. The critical question is whether your rotator cuff is intact, since this determines whether anatomic or reverse replacement is appropriate - a distinction that significantly affects outcome.

Common questions

What is the difference between anatomic and reverse shoulder replacement?
Anatomic total shoulder replacement preserves the normal ball-and-socket anatomy and requires an intact rotator cuff to function well. Reverse total shoulder replacement switches the ball and socket positions, allowing the deltoid muscle to power the shoulder when the rotator cuff is absent or irreparably torn. Using the wrong type for your anatomy leads to poor outcomes.
How long does a shoulder replacement last?
Most shoulder replacements last 15-20 years. Reverse shoulder replacements in older patients with lower activity demands tend to last well. Younger and more active patients face higher rates of implant wear over time.

Find a Shoulder Surgery specialist for a second opinion

Search board-certified surgeons by specialty, location, and accepted insurance - free for patients.

Find a specialist About Shoulder Replacement
All second opinion guides