Skip to main content
Knee ReplacementSecond Opinion Guide

Should you get a second opinion for total knee replacement?

Total knee replacement is a major surgery with a 1-2 year recovery arc and a prosthetic that may eventually need revision. A second opinion is appropriate whenever the recommendation surprises you, when your pain is manageable with non-surgical options, or when a surgeon recommends surgery without first trying physical therapy and injections. Patients under 60 are especially good candidates for a second opinion, since implants wear out and younger patients may face a second surgery later.

Red flags - consider a second opinion if you notice these

  • The surgeon did not review your X-rays or MRI in your presence
  • Surgery was recommended after a single short visit with no discussion of conservative options
  • You were not told about partial knee replacement as a possible alternative
  • The surgeon could not tell you their personal volume of knee replacements per year
  • You felt rushed or your questions were not answered

Questions to ask the second surgeon

  1. 1Have I exhausted conservative options, including physical therapy and steroid or hyaluronic acid injections?
  2. 2Would I be a candidate for partial knee replacement instead?
  3. 3How many total knee replacements do you perform each year, and at which hospital?
  4. 4What implant system do you use, and why?
  5. 5What are the most common complications you see in your own patients?
  6. 6What happens if I wait 6-12 more months before deciding?

What to expect from a second opinion visit

Getting a second opinion for knee replacement typically takes one office visit with a different orthopedic surgeon. Bring your X-rays, MRI images (on CD or via patient portal), and any records from previous treatments. Most surgeons welcome second opinion consultations and will review your imaging independently. Your insurance usually covers a second opinion visit at the standard specialist copay.

Common questions

Will my surgeon be offended if I get a second opinion?
Most orthopedic surgeons expect patients to seek second opinions for elective major surgery. If a surgeon discourages it, that itself is a red flag. A confident surgeon will support your decision and may even suggest colleagues you could see.
What if the two opinions disagree?
Disagreement between two surgeons is common and useful. It tells you the answer is not clear-cut, which often means you have more time to try conservative treatment. You can always consult a third surgeon or return to your original doctor with the new information.
Does insurance cover a second opinion for knee replacement?
Yes, in most cases. Most major insurance plans cover specialist visits for second opinions at the standard copay. Call your insurer before the visit to confirm, and use an in-network surgeon to minimize out-of-pocket cost.
How long can I safely wait before having knee replacement?
For most patients, waiting several months or longer does not worsen outcomes. Knee replacement is elective in the vast majority of cases. The right time is when pain and functional limitation become unacceptable despite conservative treatment - not on a fixed schedule.

Find a Knee Replacement specialist for a second opinion

Search board-certified surgeons by specialty, location, and accepted insurance - free for patients.

Find a specialist About Total Knee Replacement
All second opinion guides